Reviews 2005 - Round 15 PDF Print E-mail
Date: 16/12/2005 
Pie: 
 M&S Connoisseur Mince Pies
Cost: £2.99
Score: 79%
What a pie!
We have a new leader with a score of 35.58 (79%)

This is the first time that we have seen 5's scored.
Presentation scored a massive 4.42, and weight an extreme 4.50
It was only let down by its Aroma.

Many thanks P for finding an excellent pie....

The bar has just bee raised for that Mr Kipling's Luxury pie...


 Pie Scores (0 to 5) 
Visual Presentation:    4.42
Aroma:    3.08
Sugar Coating:   3.58
Size:   4.33
Weight:   4.50
First Impressions:   4.33
Crust Thickness/Quality:   3.58 
Filling Quality:   3.83
Filling Quantity:   3.92
  
TOTAL (of 45)   35.58 (79%)
VFM:   0.71
SD:   2.65

Reviewers Comments and Guessed Origin
"Marvelous Pie, so full and fat and round... Hmmmm..."
"Harrods Economy Range"
"Mr Kipling Luxurious Pies"
"Presentation better than the pie itself"
"Kipling finest"

User Comments
Please login or register to add comments

View My Portfolio

Follow Mince Pie Club on Twitter

Home
News
Reviews 2011
Reviews 2010
Serving Suggestions
Pies in Peculiar Places
Pimp My Pie
Recipes
Downloads
History
Reviews 2009
Reviews 2008
Reviews 2007
Old Reviews
Search
FAQ's
Links
Twitter
Contact Us
Flickr Photos
Flickr Photos Tagged 'mincpeclub'
RSS 2.0 Feed
Best Mince Pies in 2010
Pie Score
Harrods Mince Pies - With Malt Whisky £7.95  73.13%
Kirkland Mince Pies from Costco £3.99 for 11  71.33%
Marks & Spencer Classic Butter Rich Mince Pies £1  68.60%
Holly Lane - 6 Luxury Mince Pies (Aldi)  65.00%
Mr Kipling - 6 Exceedingly Merry Mince Pies  58.33%
Statistics
Visitors: 696516
©2012 Mince Pie Club.
Site Designed, Mambo CMS Configured and Hosted by Web-Tastic